The best white elephant gag gifts are cheap, silly and safe to open: a rubber chicken, a giant gummy bear, a garden gnome. Pick something that gets a laugh from whoever unwraps it and that people will want to steal. Ten ideas are below, each with a link, plus what to skip.
These are Amazon search links. If you buy through them, HowToRevenge earns a small commission at no cost to you. We have not tested these items. They are common novelty categories, so read the listing and the reviews before you buy.
What makes a good gag gift
Three rules cover most of it.
- It should work in the first five seconds. If you have to explain the joke, it is the wrong gift.
- It should be safe. Nothing that stains, breaks, stings or scares someone for real.
- It should be kind. The laugh is for the person who opens it, not at their expense.
How to pick for the exchange
House rules for a white elephant exchange vary, so ask the host first. Then:
- Know the cap. Stay near it. A gag gift that costs far more than the others stops being a gag.
- Know the crowd. Mixed ages call for a clean joke. Save the gross one for a group that asked for it.
- Think about stealing. A gift people want to steal makes the game better. The rubber chicken and the slippers are good at it.
- Wrap it so it hides the joke. A box that gives the joke away spoils the unwrapping.
10 white elephant gag gifts
- Rubber chicken. The classic. It is dumb, it is rubbery and it needs no explanation. Search: rubber chicken.
- Giant gummy bear. A gummy bear far too big to finish alone. Buy it sealed and check the listing for the real size. Search: giant gummy bear.
- Funny garden gnome. Works for anyone with a yard and a sense of humor. Search: funny garden gnome.
- Novelty slippers. Oversized feet, animal paws, a cartoon face. Someone will wear them for the rest of the party. Search: funny novelty slippers.
- Bacon bandages. A first aid joke that needs no explanation. Search: bacon bandages.
- Pet rock kit. A rock, a tiny carry box and a very serious manual. Search: pet rock kit.
- Whoopee cushion. Old, loud and still funny to a room of adults. Search: whoopee cushion.
- Dad joke book. Small, flat and easy to mail. It keeps paying off long after the party. Search: dad joke book.
- Inflatable costume. For the brave person who wants to open it in front of everyone. Adult sizes only, and read the size chart. Search: adult inflatable costume.
- A box of nothing. A gift box with a joke label and nothing inside. Search: box of nothing gag gift.
Make your own. A gag gift you made yourself beats most store bought ones. Our edible fake poop recipe works for adults who like a gross joke. For a kids’ exchange, a jar of homemade slime is safe and fast. More homemade fakes are on the how to make fake everything page.
Wrap it badly on purpose. Put a small gift in a box, put that box in a bigger box, and repeat three times. Nobody guesses what it is.
Mail the joke instead
A white elephant gift sits in a pile at a party. A prank gift goes to one friend who will laugh when it lands. If your friend is across the country, send the rubber chicken to their home with a short note, or see the prank mail GlitterBombTrap is getting ready. One gift to one friend is the whole idea. If a person asks you to stop, stop.
What to skip
- Anything that tampers with food or drink. Do not touch what someone eats or drinks.
- Anything that damages someone’s property or makes a mess they have to clean up for real.
- Anything aimed at a person who did not sign up for the joke, or that makes fun of their body, health, money or family.
- Anything that looks like a real legal or government notice. It is not funny when it lands.
- Anything you would not want to explain to the person’s face.
FAQ
What is a good white elephant gag gift under $20?
Start with the small items above: a whoopee cushion, a dad joke book, bacon bandages or a pet rock kit. Prices change, so check the listing before you buy. Agree on a spending cap with the group first, so nobody feels they brought the wrong gift.
For more harmless classics like a giant rubber chicken, browse our prank shopping list.
What are some things I can send anonymously?
A card, a small gift or a harmless joke for a friend who will laugh. Anonymous only means the person does not know it was you at first. It is not secret from a court. Never send anonymous mail to someone who asked you to stop, and never send a threat.
Is sending prank mail illegal?
A harmless joke for a friend who will laugh is not a crime by itself. Threats, harassment, dangerous items and repeated unwanted mail to one person can be. Skip anything that looks like a real legal or government notice. This is general information, not legal advice.
Can I mail a gag gift to a friend?
Yes. Many stores let you ship a gift to a friend’s address with a gift note. Pick an item that is safe to open, keep the joke friendly, and send one gift to one person. Read the store’s shipping rules before you order.